Silence Lifts in Statehouses as Harassment Scandals Bring Swift Penalties
Women continue to come forward, writing public letters about abuses ranging from lewd comments to groping, and joining others in a wide range of industries where powerful figures have been toppled, seemingly by the week, in the wake of the Harvey Weinstein scandal. As a result, legislators have resigned or have been removed from posts, sexual harassment policies have been revised, women’s caucuses have been formed and broad investigations have kicked into gear.
So far, many of the accused have held on to their seats — if not their stature. Some of the accusers have raised questions about whether they are witnessing the beginning of a systemic change or a short-lived political Band-Aid.
“Now they’re doing this because — why?” asked Denise Rotheimer, a political activist and Republican candidate for the Illinois House of Representatives. She complained last year that State Senator Ira Silverstein, the chairman of the Democratic majority caucus, had sent her midnight messages and asked numerous personal questions when she tried to work with him on a bill. “Because the media grabbed onto this? Because now it’s public? Because there’s nothing different from my complaint in November last year to my testimony this year.”
Ms. Rotheimer testified late last month at a state legislative hearing on a fast-moving measure addressing sexual harassment; within a day Mr. Silverstein had resigned his leadership position, though he disputed the charges, according to The Chicago Tribune. (Messages left with his office were not returned.) Lawmakers then moved quickly to appoint an interim legislative inspector general to lead the office charged with receiving and investigating complaints, after the position had sat vacant for about three years.
The upheaval in Illinois is one of many in recent days. And with so many allegations, the speed of repercussions has picked up.
This month, the speaker of the Kentucky House of Representatives, Jeff Hoover, was reported to have secretly settled with a staff member over claims of sexual harassment. The Republican governor, Matt Bevin, and eight of Mr. Hoover’s fellow Republicans in the House demanded his resignation. Last week, Mr. Hoover stepped down as speaker, though he remained in his House seat. Three other Republican lawmakers — who were also named in the Oct. 25 settlement, The Courier-Journal of Louisville, Ky., reported — were removed from their committee leadership posts pending an investigation.
The president of the Florida Senate ordered an independent investigation and took a powerful chairmanship post from State Senator Jack Latvala, a fellow Republican, who last week was accused of inappropriately touching or making derogatory comments by several women who work at the State Capitol.
On Wednesday, MinnPost, an online news site, reported that several women had described Minnesota State Senator Dan Schoen, a Democrat, making unwanted advances or even grabbing them, prompting immediate calls for his resignation from his fellow lawmakers, including the Senate minority leader and Gov. Mark Dayton, both Democrats. (Mr. Schoen, in a statement, said the allegations were “either completely false or have been taken far out of context.”)
And The Denver Post reported on Friday that Representative Steve Lebsock, a Democrat in the Colorado House, had been accused of sexual harassment by his colleague and fellow party member Faith Winter. House Speaker Crisanta Duran, also a Democrat, quickly urged Mr. Lebsock to step down, and he later apologized for “offending” Ms. Winter.
Both political parties have had to reckon with sexual misconduct allegations as an urgent threat to their power.
“This is a real issue and you want to do the right thing,” said Kent Redfield, a professor emeritus of political science at the University of Illinois at Springfield. In Illinois, Democrats have controlled both chambers in the State Legislature since 2003. “But it is also a potentially very damning political issue when the Democrats have been in charge.”
That dynamic is now in play in Kentucky, where Republicans won complete control of the Legislature last year for the first time in nearly a century. The Democrats they ousted were only two years removed from a sexual harassment scandal that led to the resignation of a Democratic state representative, John Arnold.
So when the Republican House majority leader, Jonathan Shell, insisted on the caucus’s full support for Mr. Hoover in the days after news broke of the sexual harassment settlement, the partisan backstop was unlikely to hold.
“I’m not going to condone or justify inappropriate behavior between membership and staff,” said Representative Robert Benvenuti, a Republican who was a member of the panel investigating Mr. Arnold in 2014.
This month, he was among the eight lawmakers publicly demanding the resignation of Mr. Hoover and others. Mr. Hoover admitted to the settlement in a news conference last week, though he said that the behavior — consisting of “inappropriate text messages”— was consensual and that he was stepping down as speaker mainly to keep the Legislature’s focus on a hotly debated pension crisis.
Mr. Benvenuti and his colleagues maintain that the only acceptable resolution is the resignation of Mr. Hoover and of the other legislators involved.
“There is enough distrust and thoughts of hypocrisy about people in government,” Mr. Benvenuti said. “We’ve got to do our best in gaining some trust back.”